Powder River Pizza in Sheridan

Prompt service. Good variety of food and beers.

I try not to do many negative posts on here but damn... Went in to a messy dining are but thought we could be at the end of a rush. Nope, just a staff that didn't care. Forgot our drinks. Took order and I asked for jalapenos on the pizza. When it arrived, no jalapenos. When I asked waitress about it, she brought a ramekin with no joke, 6 jalapeno slices. It stayed bad but I'll close by saying that they refused to take the pepper upcharge off.

This place was delicious! We had the nachos and two pizzas. I know nachos and pizza sound ludicrous, but Powder River Pizza make it work. The pizza was well baked, good flavor, and lots of options. Waitress was nice. It was a great experience. I don't know if I'll come here again, based on overall price. It's quite pricey for pizza. Overall great experience.

Food was pretty good. I personally think it was over priced. 16.50 for fish and chips, I mean, come on. Lots of tourists around I get it

Gluten free to the complete! Beer, pizza, appetizers, and deserts! I love this place! Doesn't taste gluten free as so many other places have tasted. This is now my go to restaurant! Love it!! Highly recommend!!

Fantastic pizza, super good beer from a local brewery (try the Saddle Bronc Brown Ale!), and great service in a fun atmosphere!

A delicious local pizza place with unusual and unique pizza toppings! Looove the enchilada and bbq cheeseburger pizza! Plus you can get a sampler and try four different kinds all at once!!

Great food and service. Not many places still run an arcade like theirs.

Great stop off on a long road trip. Fresh ingredients, friendly and fast service. Wish I could have stayed for a beer or two.

Great unique pizza recipes

Great service and huge selection of menu Items. I had the chicken and it was so fresh and tender. Good dessert options with cheescake and wilcoxins ice cream. Open, not loud, and very clean.Breadsticks are very unique and amazing!

I called in for takeout. My pizza was ready when promised. The p eff ople there acted like they appreciated my business. My pizza was good.

The pizza is good, and they took great steps to correct a mistake that they made. My problem is the price. $45 for two large pizzas seems pretty expensive. The pizza is good; it's not THAT good.

Had the Wyoming Cowpoke pizza. It was fantastic. Great service. Highly recommend

Great pizza. Great service

Good pizza and cold beer

The pizza was delicious but we ordered the nachos and I’m not sure where the $14 worth of nachos was because it was basically just chips

Service was prompt, polite and informative. The individual pizzas with breadsticks were delicious! I highly recommend the Thai Chicken.

Best pizza in Wyoming. Every time I go to Sheridan I eat there! Their Bacon is incredible!

Payed for my pizza twice. Unsure if the waitress was un attentive or just plain dishonest. Being I had been drinking. Was unsure if the staff would have brought Sheridan PD into play. So............Also.......... The young man whom does delivery. Needs to be so much more attentive to people crossing the street. Should have called his plates in that afternoon.

We were just driving through and actually looking for a different place to have dinner. We couldn't find the other place so we stopped here. What a great twist of fate! I had some Italian sandwich (can't remember the name of it). It was SO good! I wish I lived near there so I could go back more often.

Very good american pizza!

Great tasting pizza in on open, clean, inviting space. Choose from several specialty pizzas (such as Thai Spice), or build your own. Very good COVID policies. Friendly servers, good place for families. They serve alcohol. Prices are a little on the high side, but worth the stop.

I cannot say enough about the quality of service and excellent food we have every time we are guests at Powder River Pizza. I’ve been there with my family, co workers, dang near an entire softball team ... every time, outstanding service and food. Manager Mike Brown treated us like we were long lost friends - and we have nothing but exceptional servers. Even with the large party of ball players - we never felt as though we had to wait. And the food - you won’t find a better tasting pizza. It is outstanding. Highly, highly recommend when traveling through Sheridan!

Tons of good pizzas! Staff was friendly (Julia M) and the atmosphere was appropriate for the town. I'd post a pic but I ate the food so fast!

Great pizza. The staff are competely awesome. We had the taco pizza. Josh our server was fast, friendly, checked on us often. In the mood for great pizza go here!!!

Gals working are always so pleasant and speedy...remember to tip your servers and phone order takers!!

Love their creative pizza combinations.

Hands down some of the best pizza on planet earth. Try the filly pizza and an order of beer rocks, you will not be disappointed.

The Cowboy Joe meat pizza was really good. One of the better pizza's I've ever had.

The pizza was great. We had a bit of confusion on who our waitress was, but it eventually got sorted out and the drinks and pizza followed quickly thereafter. Was great for catching some of the sports events. As far as capacity is concerned, they seemed capable of handling larger parties.

Great food, friendly staff. I would go back again.

The website says that they close at 9 PM. We got there at 8:30 and as soon as only one of us stepped inside an overweight man rounded the corner, chewing nonchalantly on his own piece of pizza. He just looked over at us as he went to stand by the empty salad bar and said, “We just,” he chewed noisily, “shut down a few minutes ago.”We will never attempt to come here again. So congratulations, overweight man. (By the way, lay off on the pizza.)

The pizza was a 3 star pie. The staff was friendly and fairly quick, but my review is based off the pie alone.

Great staff and amazing food. Extremely personable and giving back through pizza for a cause.

My kids' favorite. Definitely recommend it. Don't forget to save your crusts and eat them with honey provided on the table. Everyone is friendly and service is quick. I left a tip almost as big as my bill.

Good pizza and appetizers. Sometimes the food takes a while to be made but the waiters are attentive.

For a pizza place, the nachos are awesome! As for pizza if you love meat get the cowboy, it'll feed a family.

This was the best pizza I have ever had in my life. The crust is to die for and if you order it they thought of every last detail to make sure that your experience is great. I totally recommend this place weather your just stopping in Sheridan or not you NEED to come here is a must have. P.S. the service is also great and fast.

Not just for pizza, which is excellent, this place has all the beer selection you need and all the food is great. Best salad bar in town, too!

Worst pizza I've ever had soggy crust called and all they did was hang up on me no solution to the problem

The space is open and clean, but the service was really lacking. We couldn't find anyone when we walked in and had to keep getting our server's attention for basic things, like water refills. There weren't many people in the restaurant, but the staff was extremely preoccupied with talking amongst themselves. The food was fine, but a bit overpriced.

Loved the pizza, had the German and it was delicious! Wish prices were a bit less, we got two pizzas and one drink and came to 60$ with tip, awesome waitress staff, very accommodating,

Food was delicious--we had a Thai salad and a Greek pizza. The server was super nice and helpful and delivered perfectly for a vegan and a vegetarian. Beers were only $5, and there was a selection of local Sheridan brews. The vibe was chill, modern, but still very cowboy-Wyoming-ish. Expectations were far exceeded. Thank you!!!!

Menu does not reflect true price, ordered a taco pizza which was alright. Smaller than normal $27 for it though I am going to complain. The service was fast the staff was friendly. However the size vs $ is not even remotely what it use to be. Also we had doritos on the pizza instead of the normal chips (it was delicious) however if you change something on a pizza or it is not what the menu says PLEASE let the customer know.

We’re from out of town. We found a great local pizza place and ordered carry-out at 6:51 from a local brewery. It was estimated at 25-35 minutes pickup. I walked to the establishment to pick up the pizza at 35 minutes later. I waited at the cash register for my order to come up and someone who appeared to be the manager told me “it’s not going to help get your pizza faster standing there with your arms crossed, glaring”. One hour later I get my pizza. Tastes great but please be realistic with estimated time, carry-out or otherwise!! I’m giving 2 stars for service and 4 stars for taste.

We have ordered takeout broasted chicken many times. And it has been good for the most part. Until last night, the chicken had been precooked and then cooked again when we made the order it was dry and burned up and overcooked. Tried to talk to the manager about it ,but she wouldn't listen, and would not accept any responsibility. Won't go there again, and recommend that you do not go there.

We couldn't find many places that were open when we got to Sheridan but I saw this place! The pizza was the best my family has ever had and we are pizza connoisseurs. Food was out fast and everyone was nice. Also their thick crust is to die for!

Just ordered delivery for the first time it was awful. The food was cold, dried put from sitting under heat lamps, and the ranch was the only thing in the whole meal that was hot gross..... needless to say we will not order from here again.

Went to school with the owner. Other than that PRP is fn awesome.